Best Quesadilla Maker


Ever tried quesadilla and fell in love with it after one bite? If you are eager to taste that bursting Mexican flavor on your tongue but too lazy to go out, then a quesadilla maker is the answer to your predicament. It is time to forget about the hassle of going to a restaurant just for a quesadilla. You can now make this Mexican snack right from the comfort of your own home. After careful research and product testing, we are giving the best quesadilla maker in today’s market.

Our Pick: Betty Crocker BC-2958CR Pizza Maker

Betty Crocker BC-2958CR Pizza Maker is one versatile kitchen tool because it can quickly make perfect hors d’oeuvres, giant cookies, croissants, quiches, mini frittatas, nachos, flatbreads, and of course – 12-inch pizzas and quesadillas. In particular, your homemade pizzas will surely have a crispy, delicious crust, thanks to this product’s non-stick coated baking plate. This quesadilla maker is exciting to use, as well as convenient due to its energy efficiency and easy cleanup feature. It saves you from the hassle of using an oven just to make simple baked goodies.

However, if you love baking in the oven to create more complex desserts, then you might enjoy looking at our lists of the best pie plates and cake pans. Also, your safety is a priority when you use the oven, so check out our take on the most reliable oven mitts.

Runner Up: Hamilton Beach 25409 Quesadilla Maker

Hamilton Beach 25409 Quesadilla Maker can successfully bake one sizzling hot quesadilla in just five minutes while ensuring restaurant quality. It can also provide six wedges for the quesadilla. Its nonstick surface is so easy to clean that you can just simply wipe it. The lid can be locked to avoid the mess and promote upright storage. This quesadilla maker conveniently has power and preheat light indicators.

Also Great: Nostalgia EQM200 6-Wedge Electric Quesadilla Maker

Nostalgia EQM200 6-Wedge Electric Quesadilla Maker takes baking quesadillas up a notch with its three-minute guarantee. However, the duration can be adjusted if you prefer to bake quesadillas longer up to seven minutes. The drip tray is removable for easy cleanup. This quesadilla maker has a unique feature. It has a couple of position latches so you can bake either a thin- or thick-stuffed quesadilla.

Also Great: Santa Fe Quesadilla Maker

Santa Fe Quesadilla Maker can bake 12-inch tortillas filled with cheese, barbecued chicken and/or grilled vegetables. It comes with recipes for more fun cooking experiences inside the kitchen. It has a “Ready” light to let you know that it is already done baking your quesadilla. You do not have to wait closely just to ensure that the quesadilla is cooked perfectly. The drip tray is built-in to easily catch grease, oil, filling bits, melted cheese, and other residues. Also, the housing is cool to touch during the baking process for your safety. There is even a steam guard in this product. Removing the quesadilla is too easy with this kitchen tool because of its non-stick Teflon-coated metal cooking plates.

Also Great: El Paso 10023 Quesadilla Maker

El Paso 10023 Quesadilla Maker conveniently leaves deep creases on the quesadilla for easier cutting. It is sturdy, so it can last for several years. It has an adorable design that you will be proud to show off to your guests inside the kitchen. This quesadilla maker bakes tortillas evenly for a more delicious result, especially when it comes to browning the surface and securing the cheese’s quality. It can serve as a gift to your loved ones because of its compact design and portability.

Budget Pick: George Foreman GFQ001 Electric Quesadilla Maker

George Foreman GFQ001 Electric Quesadilla Maker is easier to use compared to a stove top and ensures better quality than a microwave. It can produce big, crunchy appetizers and snacks despite its compact design. It focuses on providing the quesadilla deep pockets so you can put more ingredients in the filling. This quesadilla maker has an outer ridge that seals the tortillas properly to prevent the filling from overflowing. Storage is too easy with this product because of its integrated cord wrap and vertical stand to fit into cramped spaces.

How to Select the Best Quesadilla Maker

In making the perfect quesadilla, you need the best quesadilla maker for the job. Here are a few features to consider in choosing an ideal one:

  • Size

    The size of a quesadilla maker depends on the size of the quesadillas you prefer to make. The tortilla size of a typical quesadilla usually ranges from six to 12 inches in diameter. Meanwhile, most quesadilla makers measure eight inches in diameter. If you prefer to make large quesadillas, then you may choose a bigger quesadilla maker that is 10 to 12 inches in diameter. We highly recommend big quesadilla makers so you can bake various tortilla sizes.

  • Speed

    The best quesadilla maker for anybody is powerful enough to bake quesadilla faster than its competitors. Speed and efficiency should be top factors to consider in order for you to determine if a quesadilla maker is functional enough to meet your needs. A high-performance quesadilla maker can cook a quesadilla in five minutes or less.

  • Nonstick

    For all kitchen tools or equipment such as panini presses and Belgian waffle makers, we generally recommended that you purchase products with nonstick plates or surfaces to get the best results out of your cooking. A nonstick surface prevents burnt or charred quesadillas. Well-coated quesadilla plates also give you an evenly baked tortilla for a tastier and more appealing result. Lastly, the cleaning process becomes quick and easy when you resort to nonstick plates.

  • Additional Features

    Other features that are helpful when you use a quesadilla maker are the “Power” and “Ready” light indicators. These features indicate whether the quesadilla maker is turned on, preheated or ready to use. Some quesadilla makers also include a timer to let you know if your food is ready to eat.

    Firm locking lids and handles are also important for you to know if a quesadilla maker is a good buy. Lids that cannot be securely closed make the cooking time longer and the mess more possible. Some latches or handles even tend to break when the quesadilla maker gets too hot.

    Make sure the lid can be locked in place and the handle is durable, so you can store the quesadilla maker upright and move it around confidently. To avoid dropping your quesadilla, consider slip-resistant grips for easy handling.

    Quesadillas are quite greasy. That’s why the best quesadilla maker has a removable drip tray. As mentioned before, the nonstick drip tray catches grease, melted cheese, and other bits from the quesadilla. Without this, cleaning will take some time and cause extra trouble for you.

    The best quesadilla maker can be versatile and useful in other ways, too. With this, you can make grilled sandwiches, pancakes, and crepes. You can even reheat burgers, patties, and sausages.


We selected Betty Crocker BC-2958CR Pizza Maker mainly because of its ultimate versatility. Buying this product is like purchasing a lot of kitchen tools at such an affordable price. The best quesadilla maker for you should be convenient to use and effectively meets your expectations. That’s why it must be nonstick and efficient. Also, it must have additional features and the right size based on your preferences.

On the other hand, for parents out there, you may also check out our take on the best cookie cutters to spice up your kids’ snacks!